651-464-6001

Carney Saves Money.Time.Hassle.

Independent Insurance Agency in Forest Lake, MN

Learn HowGet Insurance Quotes

CAR INSURANCE

CAR INSURANCE

CAR INSURANCE

Home Insurance

Business Insurance

Business Insurance

Other Insurance

Other Insurance

ABOUT

CARNEY INSURANCE

We’re an independent insurance agency serving the Minneapolis-St. Paul metro region as well as Colorado Springs. We help businesses and families protect the things that matter most to them with innovative insurance strategies.

More than
70
Insurance Companies

Saving money is easy when we automatically quote your coverage with up to 70 insurance companies.
See All Companies

Over
80
Years Experience

With more than 80 years of experience, you can rest assured that you’ve got the insurance coverage necessary to protect your most important assets.

Our History

13
Staff Members

With our team of full-time, licensed insurance professionals, we’ll be here when you need us.
Meet the Team

A Word From Tom Carney

President of Carney Insurance Services, Tom Carney, talks a bit about our history, what makes the agency different, and our values.

CLIENT

REVIEWS

  • Super kind and helpful staff!

    Annika Gunderson Avatar Annika Gunderson
    August 6, 2026

    Excellent customer service and pricing!

    Barry Brainard Avatar Barry Brainard
    July 6, 2026

    When Mary or Michelle call or email, I'm always excited to pick up! That's not normal for an insurance call — but Carney is not a your normal insurance agency. She... read more

    Joe Finley Avatar Joe Finley
    May 29, 2026

  • Tom and his team did a great job finding me great rates on the coverage I needed. I highly recommend!

    Kyle Garman Avatar Kyle Garman
    February 20, 2026

    Great Agency!

    Sean Stevens Avatar Sean Stevens
    February 19, 2026

    Michelle was very helpful with selecting our Medicare Advantage Plan and then helping us change it when an unexpected issue arose. All the more impressive because no commission was... read more

    Mark V Lofstrom Avatar Mark V Lofstrom
    February 18, 2026

  • We have had our HOA commercial insurance with Carney Insurance for a number of years now and have always been treated professionally. They respond to any correspondence promptly and get... read more

    michael paoli Avatar michael paoli
    February 10, 2026

    I was initially referred to carney insurance agency from a friend and I’m so glad he did. They helped my family not only save me a lot of money for... read more

    Holli Humber Avatar Holli Humber
    December 8, 2025

    Carney Insurance has been very good to work with. I appreciate their attention to detail and their honesty.

    Mike Severin Avatar Mike Severin
    December 1, 2025

  • She took all the time necessary to explain our options and was very helpful and professional. I would highly recommend her.

    Tom P. Avatar Tom P.
    November 12, 2025

    Michelle was great to work with. Michelle was patient and took great pains to answer all our questions and concerns. Michelle explained everything and was very easy to work... read more

    Mary Engler Avatar Mary Engler
    November 12, 2025

    Michelle is very professional and had no problems answering my questions. I'm very satisfied with her work.

    Sue Edgington Avatar Sue Edgington
    November 12, 2025
MORE

FROM OUR BLOG

Student with backpack holding books.

Insurance & College: 3 Insurance Coverage’s Affected by Back to School

October 22, 2019 The heavy slam of the car trunk underscores the close of one chapter in your child’s life;...

Man behind the wheel of a car, viewed from the back seat.

Car Insurance for College Students

Updated: November 2021 College can come with some significant expenses — from tuition to room and board. You (or your...

Woman on cell phone, knelt down next to damaged car.

What Happens If You Get Into a Car Accident Without Insurance?

Every driver wants to avoid accidents for obvious reasons, but if you’re uninsured, getting into an accident can have consequences...

Happy man in a suit sitting in a car.

What to Look for When Test Driving a Car

Test driving is one of the most important parts of buying a new car. While researching online is a great...

Save Time, Money, and Hassle on Insurance

Get Quotes Now

Skip to content